|
|
Book
Review |
|
Buisseret, David. The Mapmakers' Quest: Depicting New Worlds in Renaissance
Europe (Oxford University Press, 2003). 227 pp, $35.00. |
|
In The Mapmakers' Quest, David Buisseret
describes both the causes and implications that an explosion of mapmaking
had in Europe in the period between 1400 and 1650. A Professor of History
at the University of Texas at Arlington specializing in the History of Cartography,
Early Modern France, and the Colonial Caribbean, Buisseret's well-illustrated
volume (which includes 12 color plates) explores both advances in cartographic
skill as well as the desire of European monarchs to expand their power. |
1 |
The historical significance of maps is illuminated
via a three pronged thematic approach which seeks to expand the definition
of maps (claiming that they are more then graphic representations of the
earth's surface), places maps in a social and economic context that attests
to a larger human experience, and shows that maps are universal to human
societies everywhere. In the introduction Buisseret highlights how historians,
like J.B. Harley, have come to appreciate in recent decades that the mappaemundi
of the Middle Ages were more varied then has been imagined. After that brief
historiographical introduction, the book is divided by subject area into
six chapters which move chronologically from the influence of the cartography
of antiquity (especially that of Cladius Ptolemy) on Renaissance mapmakers
(chapter one) to the mapping of European towns and the countryside at the
turn of the 19th century (chapter six). Chapter two describes
the impact of the stylistic changes of Renaissance paintings on maps, the
advent of the "painter-cartographer," and the eventual separation of cartography
and art in the second half of the 17th century. Chapter three
places maps in a political context as testaments to the desire of the European
elites to be more effective and powerful rulers. The use of mathematical
coordinates in mapping was an important technological development which
helped to make European expansion possible in the years between 1400 and
1700. The focus on this expansion, in chapter four, is the most useful section
for the world historian, as it highlights the movement of European explorers
into the Americas (particularly the Iberian wave of expansion) and the advantage
that these maps gave Europeans when it came to controlling the New World.
The "Military Revolution" of 1500-1800 takes the focus of the book back
to the European domestic stage in chapter five with the development of military
innovations, but it also considers the more powerful European armies in
the context of building overseas empires. The latest manifestations of these
maps are described, briefly, in the conclusion. By 1700, Europe led the
world in map production, and soldiers, farmers, sailors, and administrators
were among those who used these maps frequently. |
2 |
Although focused on the innovations of early
modern European cartography, the underlying context of the book is Europe's
eventual domination of the world. Buisseret asserts that more extensive
overseas mapping meant "not only that the mind could now dwell in remote
places that could be visited through maps, plans, and views, but also that
the body could also return there, thanks to maps and charts which eventually
made the whole world the Europeans' oyster" (9). This book is a useful tool
in assessing how Europe, so small and lacking in natural resources, came
to dominate the globe and thus is a good introduction to a theme which is
essential in any study of modern world history. Discussing the reasons why
Europe "found" itself to be such a powerful force on the world stage is
an excellent topic for class discussion. |
3 |
The Mapmakers' Quest is useful reading
for instructors on the secondary and collegiate levels who are preparing
to teach the Age of Exploration, and the maps make for useful visual references
in classroom discussions. This book is also useful for undergraduate students,
but it is best used to supplement materials that give a more detailed account
of European encounters in the New World and the development of centralized
states in Europe itself. This work is in no way a total picture of the political,
social, cultural, and economic circumstances which produced these maps,
but instead represents a thoughtful commentary on the growth of their significance
in European affairs. |
4 |
Christine Contrada
SUNY Stony Brook |